top of page

Retire in Style: A Comprehensive Guide to Living off the 4% Withdrawal Rule


Retirement planning is one of the most important financial decisions an individual can make. One of the key considerations in planning for retirement is determining a withdrawal rate that will ensure that your savings last throughout your retirement. One commonly used guideline for determining a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate is the 4% withdrawal rule. This rule states that retirees can safely withdraw 4% of their savings in the first year of retirement and then adjust for inflation in subsequent years, without significantly reducing the likelihood of their savings lasting throughout their retirement. The 4% withdrawal rule has been widely studied and accepted as a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate for retirees, and is often used as a starting point for creating a retirement income plan. In this article, we will discuss the 4% withdrawal rule, its historical performance and how to use it as a guideline to create a sustainable withdrawal plan for retirement.



Table of Contents

  1. Introduction to the 4% withdrawal rule and it's use as a guideline for safe and sustainable withdrawal rates in retirement

  2. What are the Pros and Cons of the 4% withdrawal rate during retirement

  3. Analysis of the factors that can affect the sustainability of 4% withdrawal rates

  4. Comparison of the 4% withdrawal rule to other withdrawal rate strategies

  5. Discussion on the importance of creating and understanding a withdrawal plan

  6. Steps and considerations you should take when creating a withdrawal plan

  7. Explanation of how to use different types of investments to supplement the 4% withdrawal rule to help create a sustainable income stream during retirement

  8. Tips to budgeting and managing your withdrawals to make sure the last throughout retirement

  9. Retirement Calculator Resources / 4% Calculators

  10. Conclusion


Introduction to the 4% withdrawal rules and it's use as a guideline for safe and sustainable withdrawal rates in retirement


The 4% withdrawal rate is a widely accepted guideline for determining a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate in retirement. The rule states that retirees can safely withdraw 4% of their savings in the first year of retirement and then adjust for inflation in subsequent years, without significantly reducing the likelihood of their savings lasting throughout their retirement. The 4% withdrawal rate is calculated based on the assumption that retirees will have a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds, and that the portfolio will earn an average return of around 7% per year. The underlying assumption is that by withdrawing 4% of your savings in the first year of retirement and adjusting for inflation in subsequent years, your savings will last throughout your retirement even if you experience a bear market or a period of poor returns. The 4% withdrawal rate is based on historical data and research that indicates that a 4% withdrawal rate combined with a diversified portfolio, has a high probability of lasting at least 30 years. This idea was first proposed by financial advisor William Bengen in a 1994 study. He found that during the period of 1926 to 1976, a 4% withdrawal rate in the first year of retirement and adjusting for inflation in subsequent years, would have allowed retirees to not deplete their portfolios even during the Great Depression and the two World Wars. Additionally, another study by Trinity University in 1998 found that the 4% withdrawal rate would have been successful for any 30-year period between 1871 and 1995. Lastly, another study by Morningstar in 2002 also supported the 4% withdrawal rate as a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate. The 4% withdrawal rate is based on the assumption of a diversified portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds and a long-term average annual return of 7% on stocks and 3% on bonds. This calculation is based on the historical average returns of the stock market and bond market and assumes that the market will continue to perform similarly in the future. However, it is important to keep in mind that past performance does not guarantee future results and that market conditions can change and affect the performance of your portfolio. Additionally, the 4% withdrawal rate assumes that retirees will live for at least 30 years in retirement, and that they will not have any significant increase in expenses during their retirement.

When planning to use the 4% withdrawal rule in retirement, it's important to consider the following questions:

  • How much money do you have saved for retirement? The 4% withdrawal rule is based on the idea that you can safely withdraw 4% of your portfolio's value each year in retirement, so you'll need to have a significant nest egg saved up in order to use this strategy.

  • What is your expected retirement timeline? The 4% withdrawal rule assumes a retirement timeline of 30 years, so if you expect to retire earlier or later, you may need to adjust your withdrawal rate accordingly.

  • What is your expected rate of return? The 4% withdrawal rate is based on a portfolio with a mix of stocks and bonds that is expected to return around 6-7% per year. If you expect a lower rate of return, you may need to withdraw less than 4% in order to preserve your portfolio's value.

  • What is your risk tolerance? The 4% withdrawal rate assumes a certain level of risk, as it is based on a portfolio invested in a mix of stocks and bonds. If you are not comfortable with taking on that level of risk, you may need to adjust your withdrawal rate accordingly.

  • What are your other sources of income? If you expect to have other sources of income in retirement, such as Social Security or a pension, you may be able to withdraw more than 4% from your portfolio without running out of money.

  • What is your expected inflation rate? The 4% withdrawal rate is based on historical inflation rate, if the inflation rate is higher than the historical one, you may need to withdraw more than 4% in order to maintain your purchasing power.

  • Are you comfortable with the potential of running out of money? The 4% withdrawal rate is not a guarantee, and there is a chance that you could run out of money if the market performs poorly or if you live much longer than 30 years.

It's important to consider all of these questions when planning to use the 4% withdrawal rule in retirement and to consult a financial advisor for personalized advice.


The Data behind the 4% rule


After testing various asset allocations, Bengen adopted the assumption that a retiree’s portfolio would be invested 50% in stocks (the S&P 500) and 50% in bonds (intermediate term Treasuries). Using this asset allocation, he tested a range of first-year withdrawal rates:


• 3% withdrawal rate: All portfolios lasted 50 years.


• 4% withdrawal rate: Most portfolios lasted 50 years. Retirements started in 10 of the 50 years examined fell short of this mark, although they all lasted about 35 years or longer.


• 5% withdrawal rate: More than half of the portfolios were exhausted in less than 50 years, with the worst portfolios lasting no more than about 20 years.


• 6% withdrawal rate: Only seven portfolios lasted 50 years, with about 10 lasting fewer than 20 years


Earlyretirementnow.com has an outstanding in-depth analysis of withdrawal rates if you're interested in the mathematics.


Success Rates for different SWRs, by equity share and retirement horizon (1871-2015)
Success Rates for different SWRs, by equity share and retirement horizon (1871-2015) SOURCE: Earlyretirementnow.com

What are the Pros and Cons of the 4% withdrawal rate during retirement


Pros of using the 4% withdrawal rule during retirement:

  • It is widely accepted as a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate: The 4% withdrawal rule has been widely studied and accepted as a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate for retirees.

  • It is based on historical data: The rule is based on historical data and research that indicates that a 4% withdrawal rate combined with a diversified portfolio, has a high probability of lasting for 30 years.

  • It allows for inflation adjustments: The 4% withdrawal rate assumes that retirees will adjust their withdrawals for inflation each year, which can help maintain their standard of living in retirement.

  • It can provide a predictable income stream: By withdrawing a consistent percentage of savings each year, retirees can have a predictable income stream that can help them plan their expenses.

  • It is a simple retirement system to implement: The withdrawal plan doesn't require additional analysis if you choose a safe withdrawal rate of less than 4%. Simply adjust by inflation each year to determine your income for the year.

Cons of using the 4% withdrawal rule during retirement:

  • It is based on assumptions: The 4% withdrawal rate is based on certain assumptions such as long-term average returns of the stock market and bond market and the retirement period of 30 years, which may not hold true in all cases.

  • It does not take into account taxes: The 4% withdrawal rate does not take into account the impact of taxes on your withdrawals, and taxes can have a significant impact on the sustainability of your withdrawals in retirement.

  • It does not take into account market conditions. Market conditions can vary greatly over time and have a significant impact on the sustainability of withdrawals. For example, if the market is performing poorly, a 4% withdrawal rate may not be sustainable and retirees may need to decrease their withdrawals to preserve their savings.

  • It may not be suitable for everyone: The 4% withdrawal rule is a guideline and it may not be suitable for everyone. Each retiree has their own unique circumstances and goals, so it’s important to consider these when creating a withdrawal plan.


Analysis of the factors that can affect the sustainability of 4% withdrawal rates


One of the main factors that can affect the sustainability of the 4% withdrawal rate is inflation. Inflation can erode the purchasing power of your savings over time, which can make it more difficult to maintain your standard of living in retirement. The 4% withdrawal rate assumes that retirees will adjust their withdrawals for inflation each year, but if inflation rates are higher than expected, it can make it more difficult to sustain the withdrawals.


Another important factor that can affect the sustainability of the 4% withdrawal rate is taxes. The 4% withdrawal rate does not take into account the impact of taxes on your withdrawals, and taxes can have a significant impact on the sustainability of your withdrawals in retirement.


Lastly, changes in life expectancy can also affect the sustainability of the 4% withdrawal rate. The 4% withdrawal rate is based on the assumption that retirees will live for at least 30 years in retirement, but if retirees live longer than expected, it can make it more difficult to sustain the withdrawals. Therefore, it’s important to consider your own personal circumstances, such as health and life expectancy, when creating a withdrawal plan.


Comparison of the 4% withdrawal rule to other withdrawal rate strategies


The 4% withdrawal rule is a widely accepted guideline for determining a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate in retirement, but it is not the only withdrawal strategy available. There are several other withdrawal rate strategies that retirees can consider, each with their own pros and cons.


  1. One alternative to the 4% withdrawal rule is the “bucket strategy.” This strategy involves dividing your savings into different “buckets” with different levels of risk and expected returns. For example, you might have a “cash bucket” for short-term expenses, a “bond bucket” for medium-term expenses, and a “stock bucket” for long-term growth. The benefit of this strategy is that it allows retirees to have a more flexible and adaptable withdrawal plan.

  2. Another alternative is the “floor and ceiling” strategy, where retirees set a floor and ceiling for their withdrawal rate. The floor represents the minimum withdrawal rate that retirees can live on, while the ceiling represents the maximum withdrawal rate that will not deplete their savings too quickly. The benefit of this strategy is that it allows retirees to adjust their withdrawal rate based on market conditions and their own personal circumstances.

  3. A third alternative is the "fixed percentage" strategy, where retirees withdraw a fixed percentage of their savings each year regardless of market conditions. The benefit of this strategy is that it provides retirees with a predictable income stream, but it may not be sustainable if the market performs poorly.

The 4% withdrawal rule is great tool, but it’s important to consider all options available and choose the one that best suits your own personal circumstances and goals. It’s always advisable to consult a financial advisor to help you understand the pros and cons of different withdrawal rate strategies and create a withdrawal plan that is tailored to your needs and goals if you need to.


Discussion on the importance of creating and understanding a withdrawal plan


Creating a withdrawal plan that is flexible and can adapt to changes in the market and personal circumstances is crucial for ensuring a sustainable income in retirement. One of the main advantages of having a flexible withdrawal plan is that it allows retirees to adjust their withdrawals based on market conditions and their own personal circumstances, such as changes in income, expenses, and life expectancy. For example, if the stock market is performing poorly, a flexible withdrawal plan would allow retirees to decrease their withdrawals in order to preserve their savings. On the other hand, if the market is performing well, a flexible withdrawal plan would allow retirees to increase their withdrawals in order to take advantage of the higher returns. Additionally, personal circumstances can also change over time, such as unexpected medical expenses or changes in lifestyle.


In conclusion, creating a withdrawal plan that is flexible and can adapt to changes in the market and personal circumstances is crucial for ensuring a sustainable income throughout retirement.


Steps and considerations you should take when creating a withdrawal plan


Creating a withdrawal plan that takes into account your own unique circumstances and goals is crucial for ensuring a sustainable income in retirement. Here are some tips to help you create a withdrawal plan that is tailored to your needs:

  • Assess your current financial situation: Take a close look at your current income, expenses, and savings. This will give you a clear idea of how much income you need to generate in retirement to maintain your standard of living. If you haven't done so, now is the time to create a sustainable and understandable budget. Without one, you're heading into retirement blind.

  • Set your goals: Decide what you want to achieve with your retirement savings. This could include buying a vacation home, traveling, or leaving an inheritance for your children. Having clear goals will help you create a withdrawal plan that is tailored to your needs.

  • Consider your life expectancy: As morbid as it may be, your life expectancy will play a big role in determining how long your savings will need to last. Consider your own health, family history, and other factors that may affect your life expectancy when creating a withdrawal plan.

  • Take inflation into account: Inflation can erode the purchasing power of your savings over time. Make sure that your withdrawal plan takes into account the impact of inflation and allows for adjustments to your withdrawals over time.

  • Consider taxes: Taxes can have a significant impact on the sustainability of your withdrawals in retirement. Make sure that your withdrawal plan takes into account the impact of taxes and that you take advantage of any tax-saving strategies available to you.

  • Be flexible: Your circumstances and goals may change over time. Make sure that your withdrawal plan is flexible and adaptable so that you can make adjustments as needed.

  • Seek professional advice: A financial advisor can help you understand the pros and cons of different withdrawal rate strategies and create a withdrawal plan that is tailored to your unique circumstances and goals.


Explanation of how to use different types of investments to supplement the 4% withdrawal rule to help create a sustainable income stream during retirement


Creating a sustainable income stream in retirement is crucial for ensuring that your savings last throughout your retirement. One way to do this is by using different types of investments to create a diversified portfolio that can provide a steady income stream.


One of the most common ways to create a sustainable income stream in retirement is by using bonds. Bonds are debt securities that pay interest to the bondholder. They are considered to be less risky than stocks and can provide a steady stream of income. However, it's important to note that the income from bonds may not keep up with inflation over time.


Another way to create a sustainable income stream in retirement is by using dividend-paying stocks. Dividend-paying stocks are stocks that pay a portion of their earnings to shareholders in the form of dividends. Dividend-paying stocks can provide a steady stream of income, but the dividends can fluctuate depending on the company's performance. Take a look at my Ultimate Dividend Investing guide to learn how to build a income generating portfolio.


Real estate investments such as rental properties or REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) can also be used to create a sustainable income stream in retirement. These investments can provide a steady stream of rental income and appreciation over time, but they also come with the added responsibilities of property management, maintenance and vacancies if you choose rental properties over REITs.


Finally, annuities can also be used to create a sustainable income stream in retirement. Annuities are a type of insurance product that provide a guaranteed stream of income in exchange for a lump sum payment or series of payments. Annuities can provide retirees with a steady stream of income, but they also come with fees and restrictions on withdrawals.


It's important to note that each type of investment has its own set of risks and potential rewards, so it's important to consult with a financial advisor to understand how each type of investment may fit into your overall retirement strategy and to help you create a sustainable income stream in retirement that is tailored to your unique circumstances and goals


Tips to budgeting and managing your withdrawals to make sure the last throughout retirement


Budgeting and managing your withdrawals is crucial for ensuring that your savings last throughout retirement. Here are some tips to help you budget and manage your withdrawals:


  • Establish a budget: Create a budget that outlines your income and expenses. This will give you a clear idea of how much you can afford to withdraw each month without depleting your savings too quickly. A budget also helps you understand where your money is going. Without a budget your financially blind. I have a Monthly and Yearly budget template available on my Etsy store if your looking to get started.


  • Prioritize your expenses: Assess your expenses and prioritize them based on their importance. This will help you identify any unnecessary expenses that can be cut in order to stretch your savings further.


  • Be mindful of inflation: Inflation can erode the purchasing power of your savings over time. Make sure to factor in inflation when budgeting and managing your withdrawals.


  • Review your withdrawal rate regularly: Your circumstances and goals may change over time. Review your withdrawal rate regularly and make adjustments as needed to ensure that your savings last throughout retirement.


  • Create a contingency plan: Unexpected expenses can arise. Create a contingency plan for unexpected expenses and make sure to have some savings set aside for emergencies.


  • Seek professional advice: A financial advisor can help you understand the pros and cons of different withdrawal rate strategies and create a withdrawal plan that is tailored to your unique circumstances and goals.


  • Consider alternative income streams: Consider alternative income streams such as rental properties, part-time work, or social security that can help supplement your retirement income and make it last longer.


Budgeting and managing your withdrawals is crucial for ensuring that your savings last throughout retirement. Without a solid plan in place you could run out of funds earlier than expected, which no one wants.


Retirement Calculators and 4% Calculators


Bankrate Retirement Calculator

Basic calculator to help you figure out your retirement.


NerdWallet Retirement Calculator

Visualize and make real time changes with this calculator.


SmartAsset Retirement Calculator

This calculator start with a questionnaire to help walk your through the process.


Conclusion


In conclusion, the 4% withdrawal rule is a widely accepted guideline for determining a safe and sustainable withdrawal rate in retirement, but it has its own set of assumptions and limitations. It’s important to consider all options available, take into account taxes, market conditions, individual circumstances and goals and consult with a financial advisor to help you understand the pros and cons of different withdrawal rate strategies and create a withdrawal plan that is tailored to your needs and goals. With an effective withdrawal plan in place you can forecast how much you want to save and set up a trajectory to reach that goal. Staying committed will ensure that your are ready to retire on time and as comfortable as possible given your unique plan. The longer you wait to start the harder you’ll have to work to retire.

24 views

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page